Cathy (LAURA LINNEY) needs a lump on her butt removed and someone to pick her up after the surgery. She asks Marlene (PHYLLIS SOMERVILLE), who becomes disoriented so Lenny picks up Cathy instead. Sean (JOHN BENJAMIN HICKEY) moves into Cathy’s backyard because he got beat up on the streets. Paul (OLIVER PLATT) and Adam (GABRIEL BASSO) win the local bathtub races. The event brings Cathy and Paul back together, but at the point of reconciliation, Paul confesses to an indiscretion with Tina and Cathy rejects the reunion. Meanwhile, Andrea (GABOUREY SIDIBE) breaks into the school and destroys the mural Lenny painted.