The New Career Mode is solid... And That's About It
NHL 26 is out and the big change for offline players is the revamped Career Mode. I like it, it feels more organic than the oft-recycled "You won't believe he's playing pond hockey" story that they told for too many seasons. Using energy points to build stats is pretty straight forward and the option to choose how to build your player through character answers helps build the character's personality. This was well-constructed and a step in a better direction.
So why the two star rating? I feel that everything else is a repeat or rehash of things that has been repackaged from seasons past with little improvement.
The "revamped Franchise Mode" that was carried over from NHL 25 is the same Franchise Mode from seasons' past, but with the ability to talk to players and offer NMCs and NTCs. At a bare minimum, Franchise Mode should allow the franchise the option to manage the AHL team's roster by signing players to AHL-only contracts (otherwise, players need to be sign-and-traded to be moved, which hurts morale and GM prestige.) At best, having the preseason start with an intersquad scrimmage where the roster is progressively cut down to 23 players would be amazing, enforcing the AHL's veteran's rule as a matter of in-game play would be nice, and incorporating the franchise's ECHL affiliate as a method for AHL or NHL players for gain simulated in-game experience based on assignment would be fun to incorporate.
Then there's the arenas. As someone who himself has been to 20 hockey arenas between the NHL, AHL, and ECHL, I can tell you that most AHL and ECHL arenas deserve to be experienced. But all non-NHL AHL arenas and all non-NHL PWHL arenas in the game use a generic arena template, and far too few Champions Hockey League franchises have their arenas represented in the game since most also a generic arena template. I don't expect EA to send location scouts out to ECHL arenas (would be sweet if they did), but the AHL teams, the PWHL teams, and sponsor-league teams of the Champions Hockey League should have their arenas properly represented in the game.
I don't hate the game-play, it feels realistic based on the normal ebbs and flows of a hockey game and hockey season, but I feel that having some preset gameplay slider settings defined for players would help them dial in their preferred in-game experience. The AI can really take over when it insists on having my team lose a game or get scored on, and I could understand how some players might prefer an experience where each play isn't based on ensuring in-game players hit a certain stat-line in the name of realism.
Do I hate the game? No. But at the price-point for which its being offered, I would expect a deeper Franchise Mode experience, and a deeper experience if I was playing as a non-NHL team. You can't charge people for Waygu beef and deliver loose-fried hamburger without expecting people to either complain or hold out on purchasing the game. Taking some of the feedback from the review would probably brighten the experience for NHL 27 or beyond.